Hello to the whole team and hello to @JNT_BA
I’m at 20 hours of play since the EA 4 here is my feedback a little more detailed on the subject:
Positive:
-
the passes are better (with a small improvement on the passes when you just press once on the LB or RB key)
-
AI improvement: the difficulty has been well reviewed and the Hard or Hardest mode becomes a real challenge.
-
Fixed tackle bug: when you tapped to follow you were always caught by a defender it happens less often and is more justified.
-
No more game crashes for me during these 20 hours of play
-
Offensive positioning greatly improved (even if there is still work to be done on the depth of the line and the depth of the kicker when we are in our 22 meters.)
-
The kicks seem really good to me (apart from a few bugs that make me tap backwards from time to time)
-
Complete logo creator suits me, it reminds me of RLL
-
Premiership very well done (apart from the 4 missing teams that will come soon I suppose)
-
Graphics and player’s faces (most beautiful rugby game for the moment, except for the field which deserves to be a little better done)
Points to improve:
-
Untargeted passes too random again (I make a lot of touch passes while I play a 2 against 1)
-
Ruck too linear in the way of building them, impossibility of stealing the ball even if we are outnumbered or of winning the ruck.
-
When we win the ruck it would be good if the ruck stayed in place with the ball coming out like on a scrum for the half-scrum.
-
Offside rule still too random at times.
-
Line out too random: in attack when the opponent sends on the same block he steals the ball from us all the time.
On the other hand, in defense it is impossible to steal the ball from the opponent! -
Defensive positioning on the line out and maul after line out to be reviewed (the first defender is 10 - 15 meters from the ruck)
-
Bug 1 time disappearance of the ball
-
Bug : Quick Throw dont work
-
Bug: when I kick the ball in 22 meters opponent, an opponent recovers it I come with my defender to tackle him I try to scratch the ball because there are only the 2 of us and the ruck is bugged
-
Bug: display in Premiership competition. When a player scores his name remains on display for conversions and future tries.
-
Lack of penalty and rules (penalty when a player keeps the ball on the ground or does not release the ball when he tries to steal the ball)
-
Players are badly positioned I often find myself with a lock on the wings. Mauvaka always in wings while he is a hooker. Other Premiership players too (McFarland in fly half so he is a lock).
-
Bug of the number 9 who sometimes takes too long to arrive for the ruck so I am penalized and scrum.
-
BUG : When the opponent make a maul after line out they dont out the ball i just need to press RL and i push the maul all along the field and normally its a fault and penalty for me after 3 stop.
-
Inability to kick behind a ruck the defense goes up too quickly and the kicker is not back enough.
-
When we are in our in-goal we cannot kick with A because the player automatically flattens the ball (Maybe change the key to flatten in the in-goal like Click on RStick maybe)*
Thank you if you read me I go back to refine my test of EA4.
I think that the community would need a little more communication in the future in order to avoid frustration for the players as for the developers we are here to work together so that the best rugby game can arrive.
Be strong and good luck to you for the day.